Monmouth County Republicans Demonized Trans Students and Teachers and Pushed to Close Schools. Who Did They Help?

Two businesses associated with Valerie and Frank Montecalvo gave $5,000 to a Highlands political committee supporting school board candidates. The committee ultimately reported spending nearly all its money with GallCo Media LLC.

A separate set of records places Archangel Strategy Group LLC, a consultant paid by the Monmouth County Republican Committee, State Senator Declan O’Scanlon and local school board campaigns, at a Highlands address connected through business registrations to Valerie Montecalvo.

In Middletown, businesses associated with the family contributed to Mayor Tony Perry’s campaign one day after two Chapel Hill property companies were formed. Those companies later became parties to an agreement involving an $8 million payment and the transfer of township-owned land.

These findings connect Public Record NJ’s reporting on school board elections, political media and land-use decisions, showing how the same consultants, political organizations and business relationships recur across seemingly separate local controversies.

The records do not establish that the Montecalvos directed political coverage, that contributions influenced official decisions or that school disputes were orchestrated to distract from land transactions. They show that the political network promoting local officials overlaps with businesses with interests before government.

The central question is whether the network that amplified school board outrage also promoted officials making decisions affecting donors’ financial interests while families faced school closures and unresolved educational needs.

PRNJ reviewed a year of reporting alongside additional campaign-finance and business records and sought comment from the people involved.

---

The campaign vendor behind the school board coverage

The investigation began with Middletown’s school board campaigns.

During Frank Capone and Jacqueline Tobacco’s 2023 reelection campaigns, Central Jersey Newswire published politically charged profiles promoting the candidates while amplifying anti-trans rhetoric. Their campaigns paid Archangel Strategy Group for reported media and advertising services. The outlet’s articles did not disclose that campaign-vendor relationship.

In 2023, Middletown school board candidates raised $88,268, trailing only Elizabeth, Newark and Irvington. Across the 2023–2025 period, Middletown ranked among the ten highest-fundraising school board races.

PRNJ’s November 2025 examination of those campaigns followed the politicial material beyond publication. Links moved from the outlet’s Facebook page into community groups, reaching residents in the same spaces used for neighborhood news and local discussion.¹

Business records identify Michael De Robbio as a member or manager in Archangel’s December 12, 2022 formation document. De Robbio is also publicly associated with Central Jersey Newswire as its founder and editor. Those roles connect the consultant and publication, but do not establish that individual articles were paid campaign services.²

The consultant’s work extended well beyond those two candidates. PRNJ’s Mapping Influence research identified 118 payments totaling $282,754.57 to Archangel between January 1, 2023, and November 5, 2025. The county Republican committee accounted for $84,546.10; other campaigns and committees accounted for $198,208.47.³

A broader expense review traces that work through September 2026. The county committee began reporting Archangel payments in May 2023, including recurring website and social-media expenses. Other reported clients included Republican organizations in Middletown, Aberdeen, Matawan and Holmdel; the state Republican committee; and campaigns associated with Perry, Gerard Scharfenberger, Victoria Flynn, Thomas Arnone and Christine Hanlon.

One previously underexamined client was O’Scanlon. PRNJ identified $67,000 in reported payments from his campaign to Archangel across the 2023 and 2027 election cycles, beginning with a $3,500 political-consulting payment on June 6, 2023. Later entries describe digital, media and political-consulting services.⁴

These campaign expenses identify who financed a consultant whose principal also published coverage benefiting political clients. They are distinct from the Montecalvos’ contributions.

The bumper sticker and the party’s payments

The network became particularly visible during the June 2025 controversy over a school employee’s “8647” bumper sticker.

A Turning Point USA correspondent circulated a photograph of the sticker and accused the employee of advocating violence against President Donald Trump. Central Jersey Newswire amplified the controversy and statements from Republican officials. Perry subsequently confirmed that police had investigated and questioned the employee.

PRNJ’s original examination of the episode identified two county Republican committee payments on June 24, 2025: $3,000 to Archangel for social media and marketing, and $898.65 in payroll to someone publicly identified as a Turning Point USA field representative.

The payments establish financial relationships. They do not identify who took the photograph, who supplied it to the correspondent or whether either payment covered the controversy. PRNJ’s subsequent reporting on the bumper sticker and former mayor Tony Fiore’s guillotine post drew that distinction while examining officials’ differing responses to political imagery.⁵

Readers encountering those articles in community groups saw the accusations and official reactions without the campaign-finance records documenting the publisher’s consulting relationships.

Montecalvo giving reaches beyond one party

Tracing the donors alongside those vendors, PRNJ identified $107,487.52 in monetary contributions reported since 2016 under documented name variants for Valerie Montecalvo, Frank Montecalvo and associated businesses, including Bayshore Recycling Corp., Montecalvo Disposal Services Inc. and Coastal Metal Recycling Corp.⁶

Their political history is longer and more bipartisan than that figure alone suggests. The contribution export extends to 1989 and includes more than $100,000 in additional earlier transactions. Bayshore repeatedly contributed to Middlesex County Democrats, including $15,000 to the New Jersey Democratic State Committee in 2003, two $5,000 contributions to the Middlesex County Democratic Organization in 2006, and $10,000 and $6,000 contributions to that organization in 2007.

Later filings repeatedly include Monmouth Republicans, among them O’Scanlon, Scharfenberger, Arnone, Shaun Golden, Hanlon, Perry and the county Republican committee. But Democratic giving continued, including contributions associated with Vin Gopal, Mikie Sherrill, Yvonne Lopez, Craig Coughlin and Joseph Vitale.

Industry committees also received substantial support. Bayshore reported recurring $7,200 contributions to New Jersey Organization for a Better State/New Jobs in 2023, 2024, 2025 and 2026. Valerie Montecalvo reported $5,000 to Constructors for Good Government in 2022.

The pattern is sustained bipartisan giving, with recurring Monmouth Republican relationships in more recent years.

Hudson Kids First changed officers before paying GallCo

Within that giving, Hudson Kids First provides a direct connection to school board advocacy. Its filings also show a leadership change shortly after formation.

ELEC received the committee’s initial registration on September 6, 2024. It identified Cynthia Fair, an executive employed by Bayshore Recycling Corp., as chairperson and Kimberly Spatola, an educator employed by the Hazlet Township School District, as treasurer. The committee registered as a county or local continuing political committee, listed its political affiliation as nonpartisan and described its objective as supporting Henry Hudson Regional School District candidates.⁷

Nineteen days later, on September 25, ELEC received an amended registration explicitly marked “UPDATING CHAIRPERSON AND TREASURER.” It replaced Fair with Donica Basinger, whose occupation was listed as merchandiser and employer as the LEGO Group. Philip Spatola, listed as retired, replaced Kimberly Spatola as treasurer. Both registrations listed the same committee address: 158 Linden Avenue, Suite B, Highlands.⁷

Philip is Kimberly Spatola’s husband. Kimberly brought an established Republican political history to the committee. A March 2009 Monmouth Journal profile described her as a former Atlantic Highlands councilwoman and then-member of the Henry Hudson Regional Board of Education announcing a bid for county freeholder, the office now called county commissioner.

“I’m a team player,” Spatola told the newspaper. “I want to be part of the Republican Freeholder team.”⁸

Its nonpartisan designation did not erase that political history.

Bayshore Recycling reported a $2,500 contribution on September 25, 2024, the same date ELEC received the officer-change amendment. Montecalvo Disposal Services reported another $2,500 on September 28. The records do not establish the sequence of the amendment and contribution within September 25, or why the officers changed.

Fair was the founding chairperson, but had been replaced before the reported GallCo payments.

Monmouth County tax records identify Arthur V Gallagher, II as the owner of 58 Linden Avenue, the committee’s registered address. The owner’s listed mailing address matches the post-office box reported for GallCo Media payments.

Nearly all the committee’s money went to GallCo

Hudson Kids First’s fourth-quarter 2024 report listed $14,500 in receipts and $13,494.27 in expenditures. Of that spending, $13,489.28 went to GallCo Media LLC: $6,970.05 on October 22 and $6,519.23 on November 6, both described as political consulting. The remaining $4.99 was a bank charge.⁹

The report classified those payments as operating disbursements. It reported no direct candidate contributions and no Schedule 11 independent expenditures. Those categories do not explain what services or communications GallCo produced.

In July 2025, Hudson Kids First paid its remaining $1,005.73 to GallCo for media consulting. Across those reporting periods, GallCo received $14,495.01, accounting for all the committee’s reported spending except the bank charge.

In March 2026, Basinger and Philip Spatola, the officers identified in the September 2024 amendment, certified the committee’s finalization.¹⁰

Gallagher had previously promoted Spatola’s political activity

Kimberly Spatola also appeared in Art Gallagher’s earlier political publishing.

In an October 25, 2018 MoreMonmouthMusings post, Gallagher praised political material involving Brian Boms, Jim Murphy and Kim Spatola, referring to them as “our friends in Atlantic Highlands.” The post documents favorable coverage of Spatola years before Hudson Kids First’s formation.¹¹

The post documents earlier favorable coverage and familiarity. It does not establish that Spatola paid for coverage or that Gallagher later directed Hudson Kids First.

On March 24, 2021, Gallagher announced that MoreMonmouthMusings had been sold, saying new owners would take over the following month. He did not identify the buyers in that announcement. The site’s publicly displayed archive ends in March 2021.¹²

The announcement predates Hudson Kids First by more than three years and does not establish an ownership or financial connection between the blog and Central Jersey Newswire.

The sequence connects a committee founded with a Bayshore executive as chairperson, two business contributions and subsequent spending under replacement officers. The filings leave unanswered what GallCo produced, who selected it and whether contributors directed its work.

Where Art Gallagher enters the public record

Gallagher also appears in litigation involving the school district and political media. That record must be distinguished from Hudson Kids First’s spending: GallCo Media and Archangel Strategy Group are separately named companies, and their receipts cannot be treated as one firm’s revenue.

Gallagher is a named defendant in Daniel Rodrick’s lawsuit involving the Middletown school district, alongside a defendant identified in the litigation as Archangel Strategies. PRNJ’s reporting on the complaint described allegations that political consultants helped prepare or coordinate material appearing on Central Jersey Newswire about Rodrick, a Middletown teacher and the mayor of Toms River.

Rodrick alleged that employment actions and the dissemination of records were connected to political disputes after he terminated municipal contracts. Those are his allegations, not findings establishing a retaliatory scheme.

The school-district defendants subsequently denied substantive allegations and filed a crossclaim seeking contribution or indemnification against Gallagher, Kevin Geoghegan, Archangel Strategies and unidentified defendants. As PRNJ reported in February, that filing preserved their ability to seek an allocation of liability if liability were imposed; it did not concede wrongdoing.¹³

The litigation gives Gallagher a documented place in the dispute over political consulting, media activity and school governance. It does not resolve his ownership or operational role at Archangel, the relationship between the litigation’s company designation and the registered LLC, or the ownership and management of GallCo Media. De Robbio’s identification in Archangel’s formation records does not settle those separate questions either.

The filings document overlapping participants, not a finding of common control.

The Highlands business address

Business records provide another connection. Archangel’s status report lists its main address as 165 Bay Avenue, Unit 2, Highlands. De Robbio appears at the same unit in its principal information.

A separate New Jersey entity list identifies Valerie Montecalvo as registered agent for 165 Bay Holdings LLC. Many entities associated administratively with Montecalvo use 1041 Route 36, Suite 200, Atlantic Highlands, an address Bayshore identifies as its corporate offices.¹⁴

The entity list includes recycling and property companies: Bayshore Recycling Services LLC, Bayshore Resource Recovery LLC, Bayshore Single Stream Solutions LLC, Bayshore Soil Management LLC, Recycling Technology Development LLC and the Chapel Hill companies.

These administrative connections do not disclose a lease, rent, financial concessions or an ownership interest in Archangel. A registered agent receives legal documents for an entity; the designation does not establish beneficial ownership.

The companies in Middletown’s land agreement

The Chapel Hill records connect Montecalvo-associated businesses to a specific public transaction.

Chapel Hill Farm I LLC and Chapel Hill Farm II LLC were formed on October 17, 2024, with Valerie Montecalvo listed as registered agent. On October 18, Bayshore Recycling and Montecalvo Disposal Services each contributed $500 to Perry’s township campaign. The donors were the operating businesses, not the newly formed farm LLCs.¹⁵

PRNJ’s original land-swap investigation traced the companies and an earlier account of a similar transaction in court records.

In a June 2024 sworn certification, developer Seth Gerszberg alleged that Perry told him in August 2023 about a plan under which the Montecalvo family would buy the Conway property and exchange it for township land. That is Gerszberg’s account of a conversation, not an independently established agreement.

On September 8, 2026, the Township Committee unanimously authorized an agreement to acquire approximately 83 acres along Chapel Hill Road and Kings Highway East. The consideration included $8 million and approximately 67 acres of township-owned land at Block 835, Lot 18. Chapel Hill Farm I and II and The Farm at Whipporwill LLC were identified as parties.¹⁶

The township presented the acquisition as open-space preservation, and most speakers supported it. The transferred township parcel would remain restricted. The ordinance authorized an agreement; it did not establish that the transaction had closed.

The $8 million is not a measure of the family’s profit. Deeds examined in PRNJ’s earlier reporting reflected $4.5 million and $6.8 million acquisition prices for two Chapel Hill parcels. An assessment of the transaction’s financial outcome would also have to account for the land exchanged, costs, restrictions and final terms.

Businesses associated with the transaction’s parties contributed to the mayor, who joined the committee in authorizing an exchange of cash and public land. That overlap warrants scrutiny without establishing that the contributions changed the decision.

A tenant’s deadline and a different account of timing

For tenants on the property, the transaction raised an immediate question: how much time would they have to leave?

At the September hearing, tenant Tyler Barry questioned why his household had been given what he described as 60 days to relocate. He asked why a longer period had not been offered if preservation had been contemplated for years.

Perry disputed the suggestion that the township had a certain arrangement dating to 2023. Montecalvo said serious discussions began only weeks before the hearing and described efforts to help the tenant find housing. PRNJ’s report on the final ordinance vote documented both accounts.¹⁷

An earlier account supplied to PRNJ identified an August 5 notice requiring departure by October 15, citing a change in agricultural and farming activities. Those dates differ from Barry’s description of a 60-day period at the hearing.

The same evening, the committee adopted rules permitting special events on qualifying commercial farms of at least 50 acres. Residents questioned the acreage threshold, and Perry acknowledged that the Planning Board had recommended a smaller minimum.

The timing warrants questions about who requested the rules and which properties could benefit. It does not establish that the ordinance was written for the Montecalvos.

The fire was a major loss

Years before the land agreement, Bayshore suffered a destructive fire at its Keasbey facility on December 16, 2019.

Its June 2, 2023 federal complaint against Hallmark Specialty Insurance Company and insurance broker NFP Property & Casualty Services alleged extensive property damage, interrupted operations and delayed insurance payments. Bayshore’s adjuster estimated $7,484,754 in business interruption losses alone.

The complaint identified $10 million tendered by primary insurers, $2,550,315 advanced by Hallmark by mid-2022 and a $2.5 million business interruption payment. Those identified payments total $15,050,315. The complaint did not give a final total loss or a fixed damages demand.¹⁸

The lawsuit provides financial context, but does not establish that fire losses motivated later contributions, that the land agreement financed recovery or that Bayshore was in financial distress when it acquired property.

What school families experienced

Beyond the campaign activity, Middletown families faced decisions with direct consequences for their schools.

PRNJ’s reporting on the February 26, 2026 closure vote documented a divided board, projected savings and unresolved implementation costs. Parents subsequently petitioned the state education commissioner, challenging the process and raising concerns about capacity, consultant work and student reassignment. Those claims were allegations in their filing.

After the board rejected a long-range facilities plan amendment on April 28, district leaders recommended postponing closures and consolidation for 2026–27.¹⁹

The district’s campaign and contracting relationships also overlapped. PRNJ’s examination of lobbying and the 2025 school board race found that CLB Partners listed the board as a lobbying client with $15,000 in receipts. The Aveta–Cody–Weinstein campaign reported $7,843.27 in Archangel expenses, while Proven Leadership PAC separately reported spending involving the same vendor.²⁰

Those records do not establish Montecalvo involvement in the closure proposal. They show why campaign financing matters beyond election night, when elected officials make decisions about buildings, staffing and public resources.

Those questions remain current. When Kevin Cullen received a permanent superintendent contract in October, board discussions again concerned aging facilities, financial constraints and the need for further planning.²¹

The documented consequences are disruption and unresolved needs, not a measured decline in student achievement attributable to this network or proof of deliberate harm to serve land interests.

The relationships residents could not see in one place

PRNJ’s reporting on Perry’s redevelopment and billboard-related contributors examined a separate set of indirect relationships involving $12,500 in contributions. Those findings did not establish donor influence over his decisions or Montecalvo involvement in those projects.²²

The recurring issue is the work required to see the relationships at all. Campaign reports identify contributors and vendors. Business registrations identify agents and managers. Property and municipal records identify land and transaction terms. Media articles reach residents without necessarily explaining the publisher’s consulting connections.

Read together, the records show Montecalvo-associated businesses funding school board advocacy through a committee initially chaired by a Bayshore executive, then led by replacement officers before its reported GallCo spending. They also show recurring campaign payments to consultants, administrative connections involving a consultant’s business address, and donor-associated companies becoming parties to a major public land agreement.

Whether those relationships formed a directed operation, or involved an exchange of political support for public action, remains unanswered.

Residents should not have to prove such a bargain before asking who finances political messages, who produces them and what interests those participants have before government. Those relationships are part of the public record, even when the coverage arriving in a community newsfeed leaves them out.

Requests for comment

PRNJ sought written comment from Valerie Montecalvo, Central Jersey Newswire editor Mike de Robbio and State Senator Declan O’Scanlon about the financial, business and editorial relationships described in this report.

Montecalvo was asked about Archangel’s use of the Highlands address; financial relationships involving her, associated businesses, Archangel, GallCo Media or Central Jersey Newswire; and whether office space, services or other support had been provided. The questions also addressed ownership and control of the relevant entities.

De Robbio was asked about his roles at Archangel and Central Jersey Newswire, the relationship between the organizations, and the services covered by the $67,000 in reported payments from O’Scanlon’s campaign. PRNJ asked whether those services included producing or distributing Newswire content, whether campaign representatives requested or approved articles, what role Art Gallagher played, and how the outlet discloses relationships involving consulting clients.

O’Scanlon was asked about the services his campaign purchased, whether the recurring payments reflected a retainer, his awareness of de Robbio’s involvement with both organizations, and any engagement of Gallagher directly or through Archangel or GallCo Media. He was also asked whether his campaign requested, coordinated, reviewed or approved Newswire articles about him.

Montecalvo, de Robbio and O’Scanlon had not responded by publication.

Mayor Tony Perry previously responded to a separate PRNJ inquiry about municipal infrastructure. Shortly after midnight on October 20, PRNJ asked about a drainage easement introduced at the previous evening’s Township Committee meeting, including a resident’s statement that he had sent 177 emails to the township between 2021 and 2026.

Perry responded at 11:23 a.m., before the requested noon deadline. His statement attributed the delay to uncertainty over ownership of a drainage pipe and said the township accepted responsibility after reviewing the resident’s research. It did not directly address the reported 177 emails or explain the full timeline. PRNJ incorporated his response into its report on the October 19 meeting.

At 12:26 p.m. on October 28, PRNJ sent Perry a separate request concerning $12,500 in contributions his county commissioner campaign reported from Strong America Strong New Jersey PAC, Outdoor Specialist Inc. and India Still.

The questions asked what Perry knew about the contributors’ relationships to people and companies associated with the Port Belford redevelopment and proposed digital billboards when he voted or spoke on those matters at the July 13 Township Committee meeting.

PRNJ initially requested a response by 4:30 p.m., followed up before publication and held the story until the following afternoon. Perry did not respond. PRNJ noted that in PRNJ’s report on the contributions and development interests, and no response had arrived by publication of this article.

During the same week, Facebook listed an account bearing Perry’s name among the viewers of PRNJ’s Stories, although the account did not follow the page. That activity does not establish whether Perry or someone managing the account viewed the material, or whether he received or read the requests for comment.

Summary

The public record reveals overlapping relationships. The unanswered questions concern who directed the work, what the payments bought and whether those relationships shaped public decisions.

We can only imagine what is happening in private.

Make no mistake in our position: TRANS RIGHTS ARE HUMAN RIGHTS 🏳️‍⚧️

Methodology and notes

PRNJ combined the contribution and expense analysis described below with its earlier reporting. The since-2016 contribution total groups documented contributor-name variants and excludes loans, in-kind support and negative adjustments from ordinary monetary contributions. Supported Archangel payee variants were grouped; an apparent duplicate pair of Holmdel entries dated May 20, 2025, was counted once. Totals from different periods and datasets are not added together.

---

Notes

1. Public Record NJ, “Who Paid for the Outrage? Following the Money Behind Capone and Tobacco’s Attacks,” November 18, 2025, linked above.
2. New Jersey Department of the Treasury, Division of Revenue and Enterprise Services, Archangel Strategy Group LLC, certificate of formation, December 12, 2022, and business status report, November 10, 2025. See also Public Record NJ, “Who Paid for the Outrage?”
3. Public Record NJ, “Mapping Influence and Information Flow: The Convergence of Party Spending and Political Media in Monmouth County,” November 2025, sec. 5.1, reporting period January 1, 2023–November 5, 2025.
4. New Jersey Election Law Enforcement Commission, expense export for reported Archangel payees.
5. Public Record NJ, “From Bumper Sticker to Ballot Box: Middletown’s Outrage Was No Accident,” November 4, 2025; and “A Bumper Sticker Sparked Republican Outrage. Then One of Their Own Shared a Bloody Guillotine,” November 1, 2026, linked above.
6. New Jersey Election Law Enforcement Commission, contribution export for Valerie Montecalvo, Frank Montecalvo and associated entities, 1989–2026, elec_montecalvo.xlsx, sheet 1, rows 2–275.
7. New Jersey Election Law Enforcement Commission, Hudson Kids First, Form D-4, “Continuing Political Committee Registration Statement and Designation of Organizational Depository,” received September 6, 2024, pp. 1–5; and amended Form D-4, received September 25, 2024, p. 1.
8. Brian Drinkwater, “Atlantic Highland’s Kim Spatola Announces Run for a Freeholder Seat,” The Monmouth Journal, March 2009, https://themonmouthjournal.com/atlantic-highlands-kim-spatola-announces-run-for-a-freeholder-seat-p354-73.htm.
9. New Jersey Election Law Enforcement Commission, Hudson Kids First, Form R-3, fourth-quarter 2024 report, filed January 22, 2025, pp. 1–6.
10. New Jersey Election Law Enforcement Commission, Hudson Kids First, Form R-3, third-quarter 2025 report, filed October 6, 2025, pp. 1–5, and “Continuing Political Committee Certification of Finalization,” received March 3, 2026, pp. 1–2.
11. Art Gallagher, “Best Local Political Post of the Silly Season (So Far),” MoreMonmouthMusings, October 25, 2018, https://moremonmouthmusings.net/2018/10/25/best-local-political-post-of-the-silly-season-so-far/.
12. Art Gallagher, “MoreMonmouthMusings Sold,” MoreMonmouthMusings, March 24, 2021, https://moremonmouthmusings.net/2021/03/24/moremonmouthmusings-sold/.
13. Public Record NJ, “New Lawsuit Raises Questions About Partisan Influence in the Middletown BOE,” February 3, 2026; and “District Files Consolidated Answer in Rodrick Civil Case,” February 27, 2026, reporting on Rodrick v. Middletown Township Public School District et al., No. MON-L-004118-25, including the amended complaint and February 20, 2026 answer and crossclaim. These references describe the filings reported at those dates, not a newly verified docket status.
14. New Jersey Department of the Treasury, Division of Revenue and Enterprise Services, entity list for Valerie Montecalvo; Archangel business status report, November 10, 2025. Bayshore Recycling, “Bayshore Fire Update – Company Statement,” December 17, 2019, current corporate-office contact listing, https://bayshorerecycling.com/news-and-events/bayshore-fire-update-company-statement/.
15. New Jersey Department of the Treasury, Chapel Hill Farm I LLC and Chapel Hill Farm II LLC registrations, October 17, 2024; New Jersey Election Law Enforcement Commission, contribution export, sheet 1, rows 219–220.
16. Public Record NJ, “Middletown Proposes Land Swap With LLCs Linked to Mayor’s Campaign Donors,” August 29, 2026, updated August 31, 2026, citing Ordinance 2026-3531, property records and Seth Gerszberg’s June 7, 2024 certification, exhibit A to Edward Tretter’s August 1, 2024 certification in No. MON-L-001438-24, linked above.
17. Public Record NJ, “Chapel Hill Land-Swap Ordinance Gets Final Approval in Middletown,” September 10, 2026, reporting on the September 8 hearing, linked above.
18. Bayshore Recycling Corporation v. Hallmark Specialty Insurance Company and NFP Property & Casualty Services, Inc., No. 2:23-cv-03047, complaint and jury demand, June 2, 2023, pp. 5, 7–10, 16–18. The $15,050,315 total is calculated from payments identified in the complaint, not a complete subsequent accounting.
19. Public Record NJ, reporting on the February 26 closure vote, February 27, 2026; “Parents File Appeal with NJ Commissioner of Education over Middletown School Closures,” March 7, 2026; and reporting on the April 28 long-range facilities plan vote, April 29, 2026, linked above.
20. Public Record NJ, “Few New Jersey School Districts Hire Lobbyists. Middletown Is One,” March 4, 2026, citing CLB Partners’ Form L1-A and school-election and PAC disclosures, linked above.
21. Public Record NJ, “Kevin Cullen Named Middletown Township Schools Superintendent Through 2031,” October 28, 2026, https://publicrecordnj.com/reporting/middletown-kevin-cullen-superintendent-appointment/.
22. Public Record NJ, “Billboards and Belford: $12,500 in Perry Campaign Donations Linked to Development Interests,” October 29, 2026, linked above.