Middletown BOE Reopens Closure Talks Amid Deficit and Pending Superintendent Exit

In March 2025, the Middletown Township Board of Education stood at a crossroads. Faced with a significant operating shortfall, district leaders publicly discussed closing multiple elementary schools. The proposal prompted community to rally around their neighborhood schools. In the weeks that followed, the Board adopted a 10.1 percent tax levy increase and described the decision as a bridge, one that would allow time for strategic planning and a more deliberate, data driven path forward.

Nearly one year later, the February 19, 2026 workshop meeting returned to many of the same structural questions. Consolidation and redistricting scenarios were again part of the public conversation, this time alongside updated multi year deficit projections and news that the superintendent will retire at the end of the school year. The district now approaches another budget deadline with overlapping decisions about finances, facilities, and leadership.

This article reviews the public budget record, the strategic planning process launched in 2025, and the February 19 workshop discussion as reflected in meeting materials and board presentations.

---

March 2025: Budget Gap and Levy Increase

Operating pressures framed as structural

In spring 2025, the district presented a tentative 2025–2026 budget under New Jersey’s 2 percent levy cap statute, N.J.S.A. 18A:7F-38. Budget slides reflected that a proposed 4.8 percent levy increase would still leave an operating deficit of approximately $9.8 million. Administration outlined $6,057,700 in proposed reductions across administrative salaries, support staff, certificated staff, infrastructure projects, summer programming, and technology replenishment.¹

Final April 2025 budget materials reflected a tax levy increase from $160,435,093 in 2024–2025 to $176,634,681 in 2025–2026, a $16,199,588 increase described as 10.1 percent.² State aid was shown increasing by $1,258,056, reflecting the statutory cap.³ After removal of nearly $5 million in prior year non recurring revenues, total operating revenue increased 6.80 percent year over year.⁴

During this period, school closures were presented as a structural option to address operating pressures. Administration proposed closing Navesink and Leonardo Elementary Schools and reducing the district from three middle schools to two in an initial phase, with the likelihood of additional elementary closures in later phases. Capital improvements, according to the presentation, would be concentrated in the remaining facilities.

Public comment reflected concern regarding timing, scope, and impact on educational programs. The Board ultimately adopted the 10.1 percent tax levy increase rather than proceed with closures for the 2025–2026 school year.⁵

Administration presented “Next Steps” that included continued strategic planning with the New Jersey School Boards Association and commissioning an efficiency study. Budget slides stated that the study would begin June 1 and conclude by the end of September 2025.⁶ The study was described as consisting of a Facilities Utilization Analysis and a Boundary Analysis.⁷ Slides stated that the district would “utilize results from the efficiency study to make decisions, such as downsizing the district footprint and/or rezoning schools.”⁸

Summer 2025: Strategic Planning Process

Community vision alongside facilities review

Following the levy increase, the district conducted a three part strategic planning process in partnership with the New Jersey School Boards Association. More than 200 participants across three sessions contributed to discussions about strengths, challenges, and long term priorities.

The district’s Mission Statement guided these workshops, stating:

The Middletown Township Public School District will collaborate as a unified community to empower each student to achieve their fullest potential by providing an engaging, inclusive, and safe educational environment. The District will responsibly and effectively utilize available resources to promote life long learning and responsible citizenship… The District will encourage students to develop their imagination and creativity, aspire to greatness, value diverse perspectives, and demonstrate cultural competence as global citizens to prepare for future academic, career, and personal success.⁹

Five goal areas emerged: Community Engagement, School Culture and Climate, Student Learning and Experience, Facilities and Finance, and Communication. The process concluded with a commitment that administration would develop action plans with timelines and measurable indicators of success to guide the district over a three to five year period.¹⁰

At the same time, the Ross Haber efficiency study proceeded. The original September delivery target later shifted publicly to after Thanksgiving and then to early 2026. The first formal presentation occurred January 27, 2026, followed by continued discussion at the February 19 workshop.¹¹

The study scope, as described in budget materials, focused on facilities utilization and boundary alignment, including building capacity, room inventory, enrollment projections, geocoded attendance zones, and transportation efficiency.¹² It did not expressly include a districtwide academic program evaluation or comprehensive instructional redesign.

February 19, 2026 Workshop

Facilities data and budget projections converge

The February 19 workshop meeting centered on continued presentation of the Ross Haber analysis. Discussion focused on enrollment trends, elementary building capacity, utilization rates, and long term structural sustainability. Consolidation and redistricting scenarios were discussed as tools to align district footprint with projected enrollment and operating constraints. No resolution to close schools was introduced and no vote occurred.¹³

Board President and Finance Committee Chair Christopher Aveta provided a budget update referencing a February 5 memorandum distributed to the Board. He stated that the district faces a $3.2 million shortfall for 2026–2027.¹⁴ He further stated that the tentative budget cannot be finalized until the Board determines whether closures or consolidations will occur in 2026–2027 or 2027–2028, as that decision will directly affect next year’s budget and management of the current year.¹⁵

Finance projections shared at the meeting indicated that, absent structural changes, deficits could grow to approximately $6.6 million in 2027–2028, $10.2 million in 2028–2029, and $13.9 million in 2029–2030 under continued 2 percent levy increases and stable state aid.¹⁶

Members also referenced aging infrastructure across 17 campuses and rising maintenance costs, noting that current efforts focus primarily on safety and security repairs pending development of a broader capital funding strategy.¹⁷

Public comment reflected concern from some residents that the consolidation discussions presented on February 19 resembled those raised in March 2025. Several speakers referenced the summer 2025 strategic planning process and questioned how the current facilities centered discussion aligns with the broader goals adopted at that time.¹⁸

Some speakers stated that the multi year deficit projections discussed during the workshop were not included in the budget update presented at the January 22, 2026 Board of Education meeting. They also referenced comments made by Superintendent Jessica Alfone at the January 27, 2026 meeting, when she stated, “We’re in a really different position than we were last year financially,” and added, “We were in a budget deficit that we were able to fortunately get some relief from. So, that puts us in a different position to make decisions moving forward.”

Several attendees stated that they had understood the Ross Haber analysis would serve as one data point within a broader planning framework. During public comment, some expressed the view that the discussion suggested a direction predetermined toward consolidation. One resident pleading with board members:

Anyone who accepted donations from people who benefit off of school closures. Anyone who has a campaign who’s has a treasurer who is also a treasurer of other PACs and other coalitions who benefit off of high density housing being built in neighborhoods like ours. I am going to ask that you recuse yourself from voting for school closures.

No board member responded to that statement during the public comment period.

The workshop concluded without formal action.

Leadership Transition

Retirement announced prior to budget introduction

Earlier in the week, Superintendent Jessica Alfone communicated to staff and parents that she will retire effective June 30, 2026. As of the February 19 workshop, the Board had not taken formal public action accepting a resignation, and no detailed discussion of succession planning occurred during the session.¹⁹

Under New Jersey law, appointment of a superintendent requires Board approval and contract action. The district therefore enters the 2026–2027 budget cycle and potential structural realignment discussions while preparing for a superintendent search.

What Happens Next

Budget calendar governs decisions

The Board is expected to introduce a tentative 2026–2027 budget in March, hold a public hearing in April, and adopt a final budget before the statutory deadline. Any school closure or redistricting decision would require formal Board action at a public meeting within that timeframe.

As of February 19, 2026, no closure vote has occurred, no redistricting plan has been formally adopted, and no superintendent resignation vote has been recorded in public session.¹³

The district now approaches its next budget deadline with facilities realignment, multi year deficit projections, and leadership transition unfolding simultaneously.

---

Notes

1. Middletown Township Public Schools, 2025–2026 Tentative Budget Presentation, March 2025.
2. Middletown Township Public Schools, 2025–2026 Final Budget Presentation, April 30, 2025.
3. Ibid.
4. Ibid.
5. Middletown Township Board of Education, April 2025 Voting Meeting Minutes.
6. 2025–2026 Final Budget Presentation, “Efficiency Study Timeline” slide.
7. Ibid.
8. Ibid.
9. Middletown Township Public Schools Strategic Planning Summary, Summer 2025.
10. Ibid.
11. Middletown Township Board of Education Workshop Agenda, January 27, 2026; February 19, 2026.
12. 2025–2026 Final Budget Presentation, Facilities Utilization and Boundary Analysis description.
13. Middletown Township Board of Education Workshop Meeting, February 19, 2026 Agenda and Summary.
14. Finance Committee Update, February 19, 2026 Workshop.
15. Ibid.
16. Ibid.
17. Ibid.
18. Public Comment Period, February 19, 2026 Workshop.
19. Superintendent communication to staff and parents, February 2026; February 19, 2026 Workshop Meeting Agenda.