Middletown BOE Advances School Closures in 5–4 Vote as Superintendent Retires and State Approval Looms
After a divided 5–4 vote, Middletown’s Board of Education directed school closures for the 2026–2027 budget while accepting the superintendent’s retirement — raising unanswered questions about state approval, capital costs, and transparency.
On February 26, 2026, the Middletown Township Board of Education voted 5–4 to direct administration to prepare the 2026–2027 budget including the closure of Leonardo Elementary School and Navesink Elementary School. The vote came after hours of emotional public testimony and visibly divided debate among Board members. In the same meeting, under the Personnel consent agenda, the Board formally accepted the retirement of Superintendent Jessica Alfone, effective July 1, 2026.
Taken together, those actions set the district on a course toward elementary consolidation while entering a leadership transition with no publicly outlined search process and no detailed implementation roadmap. Multiple residents referenced potential legal action during public comment. The district now moves forward with structural change amid uncertainty about oversight, continuity, and compliance.